What does “opposite” mean?What does “playus nigh” mean in Cockney?What does “good job” mean?What does “wishy-washy” mean?What does “What are you into here?” mean?What does “fiddle with that” meanWhat does word “nerd” mean exactly?What's the colloquial opposite of “do me a solid”?What does the word “waaaaay” mean?What does the description “go opposite direction of [blank]” mean?What does the term “tropical girl” mean?
How can "mimic phobia" be cured or prevented?
Are lightweight LN wallets vulnerable to transaction withholding?
What does this horizontal bar at the first measure mean?
What linear sensor for a keyboard?
We have a love-hate relationship
My friend sent me a screenshot of a transaction hash, but when I search for it I find divergent data. What happened?
How must one send away the mother bird?
How to color a curve
How do I implement a file system driver driver in Linux?
Global amount of publications over time
How can Trident be so inexpensive? Will it orbit Triton or just do a (slow) flyby?
Translation of Scottish 16th century church stained glass
Can someone explain how this makes sense electrically?
Reply 'no position' while the job posting is still there
What is this type of notehead called?
Why did the HMS Bounty go back to a time when whales are already rare?
Can the Supreme Court overturn an impeachment?
Has Darkwing Duck ever met Scrooge McDuck?
Do the concepts of IP address and network interface not belong to the same layer?
Proof of Lemma: Every nonzero integer can be written as a product of primes
Journal losing indexing services
Should I stop contributing to retirement accounts?
Does having a TSA Pre-Check member in your flight reservation increase the chances that everyone gets Pre-Check?
MAXDOP Settings for SQL Server 2014
What does “opposite” mean?
What does “playus nigh” mean in Cockney?What does “good job” mean?What does “wishy-washy” mean?What does “What are you into here?” mean?What does “fiddle with that” meanWhat does word “nerd” mean exactly?What's the colloquial opposite of “do me a solid”?What does the word “waaaaay” mean?What does the description “go opposite direction of [blank]” mean?What does the term “tropical girl” mean?
In a mathematical sense, the opposite of "X" is "not X" and this works in all cases.
But in language text books, or in common usage, there is a lot of ambiguity in "opposite".
Eg.
Father ~ Mother
Son ~ Daughter
Here, both are with reference to the speaker, meaning "my father" ~ "my mother".
Husband ~ Wife
Here , the reference point itself changes, meaning I can not have both husband and wife.
More-over, why should only the sex change for opposite ? Can Son be the opposite of Father ? Considering reversal of both characteristics, we should have Father as the opposite of Daughter, in line with the Dictionary meaning of opposite "Being directly across from each other; facing" or "Characterized by opposite extremes; completely opposed" [from wordweb].
Friend ~ Enemy, Acquaintance, Stranger ?
Uncle ~ Aunt, Nephew, Niece ?
It seems more logical (unambiguous) to use the mathematical sense : opposite of "Father" is "not Father".
In language learning books, what does "opposite" really mean ? Is it some arbitrary colloquialisms ? Is there some unambiguous meaning ?
meaning antonyms colloquialisms
|
show 1 more comment
In a mathematical sense, the opposite of "X" is "not X" and this works in all cases.
But in language text books, or in common usage, there is a lot of ambiguity in "opposite".
Eg.
Father ~ Mother
Son ~ Daughter
Here, both are with reference to the speaker, meaning "my father" ~ "my mother".
Husband ~ Wife
Here , the reference point itself changes, meaning I can not have both husband and wife.
More-over, why should only the sex change for opposite ? Can Son be the opposite of Father ? Considering reversal of both characteristics, we should have Father as the opposite of Daughter, in line with the Dictionary meaning of opposite "Being directly across from each other; facing" or "Characterized by opposite extremes; completely opposed" [from wordweb].
Friend ~ Enemy, Acquaintance, Stranger ?
Uncle ~ Aunt, Nephew, Niece ?
It seems more logical (unambiguous) to use the mathematical sense : opposite of "Father" is "not Father".
In language learning books, what does "opposite" really mean ? Is it some arbitrary colloquialisms ? Is there some unambiguous meaning ?
meaning antonyms colloquialisms
2
I'm afraid that opposite has multiple meanings language wise. So in this case maths and language are indeed different domains, no real comparison possible.
– Bookeater
Jun 8 '15 at 19:15
1
I fail to see how this is specific to English Language and Usage
– Tushar Raj
Jun 8 '15 at 19:26
@Bookeater , yes the question is about whether "opposite" has a fixed unambiguous meaning or not. I agree that it has many meanings, in general. In a specific case, I am worried why language textbooks (or Exams) will mark Father~Son , Father~Daughter as WRONG, because those are equally correct.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:09
@TusharRaj , I agree that this problem exists in many (all ?) other languages. Definitely it exists in English too. Unless a language has a FIXED Definition of Opposite, this problem will exist. Mathematics is exempted, because Opposite of "X" is "not X", with no ambiguity.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:25
1
What do you mean - the opposite of "x" is "not x" in mathematics? In the common sense of "not", 6 is not 7, but 6 is not the opposite of 7, either. So what EXACTLY do "opposite" and "not" mean in mathematics?
– user316117
May 12 '16 at 18:38
|
show 1 more comment
In a mathematical sense, the opposite of "X" is "not X" and this works in all cases.
But in language text books, or in common usage, there is a lot of ambiguity in "opposite".
Eg.
Father ~ Mother
Son ~ Daughter
Here, both are with reference to the speaker, meaning "my father" ~ "my mother".
Husband ~ Wife
Here , the reference point itself changes, meaning I can not have both husband and wife.
More-over, why should only the sex change for opposite ? Can Son be the opposite of Father ? Considering reversal of both characteristics, we should have Father as the opposite of Daughter, in line with the Dictionary meaning of opposite "Being directly across from each other; facing" or "Characterized by opposite extremes; completely opposed" [from wordweb].
Friend ~ Enemy, Acquaintance, Stranger ?
Uncle ~ Aunt, Nephew, Niece ?
It seems more logical (unambiguous) to use the mathematical sense : opposite of "Father" is "not Father".
In language learning books, what does "opposite" really mean ? Is it some arbitrary colloquialisms ? Is there some unambiguous meaning ?
meaning antonyms colloquialisms
In a mathematical sense, the opposite of "X" is "not X" and this works in all cases.
But in language text books, or in common usage, there is a lot of ambiguity in "opposite".
Eg.
Father ~ Mother
Son ~ Daughter
Here, both are with reference to the speaker, meaning "my father" ~ "my mother".
Husband ~ Wife
Here , the reference point itself changes, meaning I can not have both husband and wife.
More-over, why should only the sex change for opposite ? Can Son be the opposite of Father ? Considering reversal of both characteristics, we should have Father as the opposite of Daughter, in line with the Dictionary meaning of opposite "Being directly across from each other; facing" or "Characterized by opposite extremes; completely opposed" [from wordweb].
Friend ~ Enemy, Acquaintance, Stranger ?
Uncle ~ Aunt, Nephew, Niece ?
It seems more logical (unambiguous) to use the mathematical sense : opposite of "Father" is "not Father".
In language learning books, what does "opposite" really mean ? Is it some arbitrary colloquialisms ? Is there some unambiguous meaning ?
meaning antonyms colloquialisms
meaning antonyms colloquialisms
asked Jun 8 '15 at 18:54
PremPrem
2,78121135
2,78121135
2
I'm afraid that opposite has multiple meanings language wise. So in this case maths and language are indeed different domains, no real comparison possible.
– Bookeater
Jun 8 '15 at 19:15
1
I fail to see how this is specific to English Language and Usage
– Tushar Raj
Jun 8 '15 at 19:26
@Bookeater , yes the question is about whether "opposite" has a fixed unambiguous meaning or not. I agree that it has many meanings, in general. In a specific case, I am worried why language textbooks (or Exams) will mark Father~Son , Father~Daughter as WRONG, because those are equally correct.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:09
@TusharRaj , I agree that this problem exists in many (all ?) other languages. Definitely it exists in English too. Unless a language has a FIXED Definition of Opposite, this problem will exist. Mathematics is exempted, because Opposite of "X" is "not X", with no ambiguity.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:25
1
What do you mean - the opposite of "x" is "not x" in mathematics? In the common sense of "not", 6 is not 7, but 6 is not the opposite of 7, either. So what EXACTLY do "opposite" and "not" mean in mathematics?
– user316117
May 12 '16 at 18:38
|
show 1 more comment
2
I'm afraid that opposite has multiple meanings language wise. So in this case maths and language are indeed different domains, no real comparison possible.
– Bookeater
Jun 8 '15 at 19:15
1
I fail to see how this is specific to English Language and Usage
– Tushar Raj
Jun 8 '15 at 19:26
@Bookeater , yes the question is about whether "opposite" has a fixed unambiguous meaning or not. I agree that it has many meanings, in general. In a specific case, I am worried why language textbooks (or Exams) will mark Father~Son , Father~Daughter as WRONG, because those are equally correct.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:09
@TusharRaj , I agree that this problem exists in many (all ?) other languages. Definitely it exists in English too. Unless a language has a FIXED Definition of Opposite, this problem will exist. Mathematics is exempted, because Opposite of "X" is "not X", with no ambiguity.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:25
1
What do you mean - the opposite of "x" is "not x" in mathematics? In the common sense of "not", 6 is not 7, but 6 is not the opposite of 7, either. So what EXACTLY do "opposite" and "not" mean in mathematics?
– user316117
May 12 '16 at 18:38
2
2
I'm afraid that opposite has multiple meanings language wise. So in this case maths and language are indeed different domains, no real comparison possible.
– Bookeater
Jun 8 '15 at 19:15
I'm afraid that opposite has multiple meanings language wise. So in this case maths and language are indeed different domains, no real comparison possible.
– Bookeater
Jun 8 '15 at 19:15
1
1
I fail to see how this is specific to English Language and Usage
– Tushar Raj
Jun 8 '15 at 19:26
I fail to see how this is specific to English Language and Usage
– Tushar Raj
Jun 8 '15 at 19:26
@Bookeater , yes the question is about whether "opposite" has a fixed unambiguous meaning or not. I agree that it has many meanings, in general. In a specific case, I am worried why language textbooks (or Exams) will mark Father~Son , Father~Daughter as WRONG, because those are equally correct.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:09
@Bookeater , yes the question is about whether "opposite" has a fixed unambiguous meaning or not. I agree that it has many meanings, in general. In a specific case, I am worried why language textbooks (or Exams) will mark Father~Son , Father~Daughter as WRONG, because those are equally correct.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:09
@TusharRaj , I agree that this problem exists in many (all ?) other languages. Definitely it exists in English too. Unless a language has a FIXED Definition of Opposite, this problem will exist. Mathematics is exempted, because Opposite of "X" is "not X", with no ambiguity.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:25
@TusharRaj , I agree that this problem exists in many (all ?) other languages. Definitely it exists in English too. Unless a language has a FIXED Definition of Opposite, this problem will exist. Mathematics is exempted, because Opposite of "X" is "not X", with no ambiguity.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:25
1
1
What do you mean - the opposite of "x" is "not x" in mathematics? In the common sense of "not", 6 is not 7, but 6 is not the opposite of 7, either. So what EXACTLY do "opposite" and "not" mean in mathematics?
– user316117
May 12 '16 at 18:38
What do you mean - the opposite of "x" is "not x" in mathematics? In the common sense of "not", 6 is not 7, but 6 is not the opposite of 7, either. So what EXACTLY do "opposite" and "not" mean in mathematics?
– user316117
May 12 '16 at 18:38
|
show 1 more comment
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
This question on Linguistics Stack Exchange addresses this, asking if mother and father are true antonyms. I'll quote the accepted answer, written by robert, which basically boils down to "Technically no, but sometimes yes."
Mother is not the antonym of father. They are co-hyponyms because they are both a kind of parent - and parent is the hypernym of mother and father.
Antonymy is the relation that holds between parent and child. So by extension the antonym of mother could be said to be child.
EDIT: After reading hippietrail's answer, I somewhat changed my opinion. If one considers two words to be antonyms already if just one of their semantic features is replaced with the opposite then mother (female parent) and father (male parent) can be said to be antonyms. However, I feel that it might make sense to reserve antonymy for complete negation or oppositeness, and describe the relation between mother and father as hyponymy.
One thing to keep in mind is that language textbooks are often geared toward students who are at a very basic level of that language. For someone who is just beginning to learning English, framing words like mother and father or son and daughter as opposites is a simplification that helps students learn the proper use of those terms. In a simplified way, it makes sense: a mother is a parent who is not a father, and a father is a parent who is not a mother; a son is a child who is not a daughter, and a daughter is a child who is not a son.
This simplification serves the same purpose as the simplification often taught to children just beginning to learn division that even numbers can be divided by two and odd numbers can't. Later on, when they're more advanced, the students will learn that odd numbers can be divided by two; it's just that doing so doesn't result in a whole number. At a more advanced stage, students will learn that words like father and mother aren't true opposites like hot and cold are, but at the moment, that terminology suffices.
+1, good pointer to a related question (about antonym) from somebody who had a similar Doubt. I only gave language textbooks as an example, though the problem is more widespread ; Even common speakers (native speakers) will say Father & Mother are opposites, while Father & Son (or Daughter) can also be in "opposition" , in a sense.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:02
add a comment |
After some thinking [and the antonyms reference given by user Nicole helped a lot; user Hippietrail seems to support my thinking and has clarified a lot of things], I feel I can chip in with my own perspective on this question.
Antonymy : The semantic relation that holds between two words that can (in a given context) express opposite meanings [From WordWeb, emphasis mine]
Seems to be a good Definition, but this question is not about Antonyms, rather about what "opposite" means.
Opposite : "A word that expresses a meaning opposed to the meaning of another word, in which case the two words are antonyms of each other" & "Altogether different in nature, quality or significance" [From WordWeb, emphasis mine]
So if a word has many characteristics, then there can be many opposites, where atleast one characteristic is "negated".
Eg Father has characteristics (Male,Parent,Relative,Good,Carer,...) so opposites can be Mother (Male is negated Female) or Son (Parent is negated to Child) or Daughter (Male is negated Female & Parent is negated to Child) ...
What would be the opposite of Father in "My class teacher was like a Father who treated us like his children" ? The characteristic is "Good" and negate that to get "Bad", so "My class teacher was like a Tyrant who treated us like slaves". Of course, in general, nobody claims that the opposite of Father is Tyrant.
So I could say that "opposite" is either not really Well Defined, or any usage must state which Specific Context is being considered.
User Hippietrail rightly says that "antonym" is not really a "natural" or "God given" concept that it at first seems.
It may not matter much in daily life, but in language Exams, incorrect thinking on the part of the evaluators may result in incorrect evaluations of some "correct" answers. One way out would be to ask questions like "What is the Feminine opposite of Father ?" so that the context is shown.
add a comment |
Not doesn't mean opposite. Animals that are not birds is the set of all animals minus birds - Not means 'exclusion'.
The opposite of 6 is negative 6 - opposite meaning a measurement of the same magnitude in the reverse direction of the same continuum.
So on the continuum of approval, or morality, good is the opposite of bad.
On the continuum of personal alliances a friend is the opposite of enemy.
But titles such as Uncle are not on any continuum, they have one specific meaning. There is no opposite of Doctor, Dentist, baseball or niece.
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "97"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fenglish.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f251198%2fwhat-does-opposite-mean%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
This question on Linguistics Stack Exchange addresses this, asking if mother and father are true antonyms. I'll quote the accepted answer, written by robert, which basically boils down to "Technically no, but sometimes yes."
Mother is not the antonym of father. They are co-hyponyms because they are both a kind of parent - and parent is the hypernym of mother and father.
Antonymy is the relation that holds between parent and child. So by extension the antonym of mother could be said to be child.
EDIT: After reading hippietrail's answer, I somewhat changed my opinion. If one considers two words to be antonyms already if just one of their semantic features is replaced with the opposite then mother (female parent) and father (male parent) can be said to be antonyms. However, I feel that it might make sense to reserve antonymy for complete negation or oppositeness, and describe the relation between mother and father as hyponymy.
One thing to keep in mind is that language textbooks are often geared toward students who are at a very basic level of that language. For someone who is just beginning to learning English, framing words like mother and father or son and daughter as opposites is a simplification that helps students learn the proper use of those terms. In a simplified way, it makes sense: a mother is a parent who is not a father, and a father is a parent who is not a mother; a son is a child who is not a daughter, and a daughter is a child who is not a son.
This simplification serves the same purpose as the simplification often taught to children just beginning to learn division that even numbers can be divided by two and odd numbers can't. Later on, when they're more advanced, the students will learn that odd numbers can be divided by two; it's just that doing so doesn't result in a whole number. At a more advanced stage, students will learn that words like father and mother aren't true opposites like hot and cold are, but at the moment, that terminology suffices.
+1, good pointer to a related question (about antonym) from somebody who had a similar Doubt. I only gave language textbooks as an example, though the problem is more widespread ; Even common speakers (native speakers) will say Father & Mother are opposites, while Father & Son (or Daughter) can also be in "opposition" , in a sense.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:02
add a comment |
This question on Linguistics Stack Exchange addresses this, asking if mother and father are true antonyms. I'll quote the accepted answer, written by robert, which basically boils down to "Technically no, but sometimes yes."
Mother is not the antonym of father. They are co-hyponyms because they are both a kind of parent - and parent is the hypernym of mother and father.
Antonymy is the relation that holds between parent and child. So by extension the antonym of mother could be said to be child.
EDIT: After reading hippietrail's answer, I somewhat changed my opinion. If one considers two words to be antonyms already if just one of their semantic features is replaced with the opposite then mother (female parent) and father (male parent) can be said to be antonyms. However, I feel that it might make sense to reserve antonymy for complete negation or oppositeness, and describe the relation between mother and father as hyponymy.
One thing to keep in mind is that language textbooks are often geared toward students who are at a very basic level of that language. For someone who is just beginning to learning English, framing words like mother and father or son and daughter as opposites is a simplification that helps students learn the proper use of those terms. In a simplified way, it makes sense: a mother is a parent who is not a father, and a father is a parent who is not a mother; a son is a child who is not a daughter, and a daughter is a child who is not a son.
This simplification serves the same purpose as the simplification often taught to children just beginning to learn division that even numbers can be divided by two and odd numbers can't. Later on, when they're more advanced, the students will learn that odd numbers can be divided by two; it's just that doing so doesn't result in a whole number. At a more advanced stage, students will learn that words like father and mother aren't true opposites like hot and cold are, but at the moment, that terminology suffices.
+1, good pointer to a related question (about antonym) from somebody who had a similar Doubt. I only gave language textbooks as an example, though the problem is more widespread ; Even common speakers (native speakers) will say Father & Mother are opposites, while Father & Son (or Daughter) can also be in "opposition" , in a sense.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:02
add a comment |
This question on Linguistics Stack Exchange addresses this, asking if mother and father are true antonyms. I'll quote the accepted answer, written by robert, which basically boils down to "Technically no, but sometimes yes."
Mother is not the antonym of father. They are co-hyponyms because they are both a kind of parent - and parent is the hypernym of mother and father.
Antonymy is the relation that holds between parent and child. So by extension the antonym of mother could be said to be child.
EDIT: After reading hippietrail's answer, I somewhat changed my opinion. If one considers two words to be antonyms already if just one of their semantic features is replaced with the opposite then mother (female parent) and father (male parent) can be said to be antonyms. However, I feel that it might make sense to reserve antonymy for complete negation or oppositeness, and describe the relation between mother and father as hyponymy.
One thing to keep in mind is that language textbooks are often geared toward students who are at a very basic level of that language. For someone who is just beginning to learning English, framing words like mother and father or son and daughter as opposites is a simplification that helps students learn the proper use of those terms. In a simplified way, it makes sense: a mother is a parent who is not a father, and a father is a parent who is not a mother; a son is a child who is not a daughter, and a daughter is a child who is not a son.
This simplification serves the same purpose as the simplification often taught to children just beginning to learn division that even numbers can be divided by two and odd numbers can't. Later on, when they're more advanced, the students will learn that odd numbers can be divided by two; it's just that doing so doesn't result in a whole number. At a more advanced stage, students will learn that words like father and mother aren't true opposites like hot and cold are, but at the moment, that terminology suffices.
This question on Linguistics Stack Exchange addresses this, asking if mother and father are true antonyms. I'll quote the accepted answer, written by robert, which basically boils down to "Technically no, but sometimes yes."
Mother is not the antonym of father. They are co-hyponyms because they are both a kind of parent - and parent is the hypernym of mother and father.
Antonymy is the relation that holds between parent and child. So by extension the antonym of mother could be said to be child.
EDIT: After reading hippietrail's answer, I somewhat changed my opinion. If one considers two words to be antonyms already if just one of their semantic features is replaced with the opposite then mother (female parent) and father (male parent) can be said to be antonyms. However, I feel that it might make sense to reserve antonymy for complete negation or oppositeness, and describe the relation between mother and father as hyponymy.
One thing to keep in mind is that language textbooks are often geared toward students who are at a very basic level of that language. For someone who is just beginning to learning English, framing words like mother and father or son and daughter as opposites is a simplification that helps students learn the proper use of those terms. In a simplified way, it makes sense: a mother is a parent who is not a father, and a father is a parent who is not a mother; a son is a child who is not a daughter, and a daughter is a child who is not a son.
This simplification serves the same purpose as the simplification often taught to children just beginning to learn division that even numbers can be divided by two and odd numbers can't. Later on, when they're more advanced, the students will learn that odd numbers can be divided by two; it's just that doing so doesn't result in a whole number. At a more advanced stage, students will learn that words like father and mother aren't true opposites like hot and cold are, but at the moment, that terminology suffices.
edited Apr 13 '17 at 12:54
Community♦
1
1
answered Jun 8 '15 at 19:22
NicoleNicole
9,52574084
9,52574084
+1, good pointer to a related question (about antonym) from somebody who had a similar Doubt. I only gave language textbooks as an example, though the problem is more widespread ; Even common speakers (native speakers) will say Father & Mother are opposites, while Father & Son (or Daughter) can also be in "opposition" , in a sense.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:02
add a comment |
+1, good pointer to a related question (about antonym) from somebody who had a similar Doubt. I only gave language textbooks as an example, though the problem is more widespread ; Even common speakers (native speakers) will say Father & Mother are opposites, while Father & Son (or Daughter) can also be in "opposition" , in a sense.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:02
+1, good pointer to a related question (about antonym) from somebody who had a similar Doubt. I only gave language textbooks as an example, though the problem is more widespread ; Even common speakers (native speakers) will say Father & Mother are opposites, while Father & Son (or Daughter) can also be in "opposition" , in a sense.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:02
+1, good pointer to a related question (about antonym) from somebody who had a similar Doubt. I only gave language textbooks as an example, though the problem is more widespread ; Even common speakers (native speakers) will say Father & Mother are opposites, while Father & Son (or Daughter) can also be in "opposition" , in a sense.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:02
add a comment |
After some thinking [and the antonyms reference given by user Nicole helped a lot; user Hippietrail seems to support my thinking and has clarified a lot of things], I feel I can chip in with my own perspective on this question.
Antonymy : The semantic relation that holds between two words that can (in a given context) express opposite meanings [From WordWeb, emphasis mine]
Seems to be a good Definition, but this question is not about Antonyms, rather about what "opposite" means.
Opposite : "A word that expresses a meaning opposed to the meaning of another word, in which case the two words are antonyms of each other" & "Altogether different in nature, quality or significance" [From WordWeb, emphasis mine]
So if a word has many characteristics, then there can be many opposites, where atleast one characteristic is "negated".
Eg Father has characteristics (Male,Parent,Relative,Good,Carer,...) so opposites can be Mother (Male is negated Female) or Son (Parent is negated to Child) or Daughter (Male is negated Female & Parent is negated to Child) ...
What would be the opposite of Father in "My class teacher was like a Father who treated us like his children" ? The characteristic is "Good" and negate that to get "Bad", so "My class teacher was like a Tyrant who treated us like slaves". Of course, in general, nobody claims that the opposite of Father is Tyrant.
So I could say that "opposite" is either not really Well Defined, or any usage must state which Specific Context is being considered.
User Hippietrail rightly says that "antonym" is not really a "natural" or "God given" concept that it at first seems.
It may not matter much in daily life, but in language Exams, incorrect thinking on the part of the evaluators may result in incorrect evaluations of some "correct" answers. One way out would be to ask questions like "What is the Feminine opposite of Father ?" so that the context is shown.
add a comment |
After some thinking [and the antonyms reference given by user Nicole helped a lot; user Hippietrail seems to support my thinking and has clarified a lot of things], I feel I can chip in with my own perspective on this question.
Antonymy : The semantic relation that holds between two words that can (in a given context) express opposite meanings [From WordWeb, emphasis mine]
Seems to be a good Definition, but this question is not about Antonyms, rather about what "opposite" means.
Opposite : "A word that expresses a meaning opposed to the meaning of another word, in which case the two words are antonyms of each other" & "Altogether different in nature, quality or significance" [From WordWeb, emphasis mine]
So if a word has many characteristics, then there can be many opposites, where atleast one characteristic is "negated".
Eg Father has characteristics (Male,Parent,Relative,Good,Carer,...) so opposites can be Mother (Male is negated Female) or Son (Parent is negated to Child) or Daughter (Male is negated Female & Parent is negated to Child) ...
What would be the opposite of Father in "My class teacher was like a Father who treated us like his children" ? The characteristic is "Good" and negate that to get "Bad", so "My class teacher was like a Tyrant who treated us like slaves". Of course, in general, nobody claims that the opposite of Father is Tyrant.
So I could say that "opposite" is either not really Well Defined, or any usage must state which Specific Context is being considered.
User Hippietrail rightly says that "antonym" is not really a "natural" or "God given" concept that it at first seems.
It may not matter much in daily life, but in language Exams, incorrect thinking on the part of the evaluators may result in incorrect evaluations of some "correct" answers. One way out would be to ask questions like "What is the Feminine opposite of Father ?" so that the context is shown.
add a comment |
After some thinking [and the antonyms reference given by user Nicole helped a lot; user Hippietrail seems to support my thinking and has clarified a lot of things], I feel I can chip in with my own perspective on this question.
Antonymy : The semantic relation that holds between two words that can (in a given context) express opposite meanings [From WordWeb, emphasis mine]
Seems to be a good Definition, but this question is not about Antonyms, rather about what "opposite" means.
Opposite : "A word that expresses a meaning opposed to the meaning of another word, in which case the two words are antonyms of each other" & "Altogether different in nature, quality or significance" [From WordWeb, emphasis mine]
So if a word has many characteristics, then there can be many opposites, where atleast one characteristic is "negated".
Eg Father has characteristics (Male,Parent,Relative,Good,Carer,...) so opposites can be Mother (Male is negated Female) or Son (Parent is negated to Child) or Daughter (Male is negated Female & Parent is negated to Child) ...
What would be the opposite of Father in "My class teacher was like a Father who treated us like his children" ? The characteristic is "Good" and negate that to get "Bad", so "My class teacher was like a Tyrant who treated us like slaves". Of course, in general, nobody claims that the opposite of Father is Tyrant.
So I could say that "opposite" is either not really Well Defined, or any usage must state which Specific Context is being considered.
User Hippietrail rightly says that "antonym" is not really a "natural" or "God given" concept that it at first seems.
It may not matter much in daily life, but in language Exams, incorrect thinking on the part of the evaluators may result in incorrect evaluations of some "correct" answers. One way out would be to ask questions like "What is the Feminine opposite of Father ?" so that the context is shown.
After some thinking [and the antonyms reference given by user Nicole helped a lot; user Hippietrail seems to support my thinking and has clarified a lot of things], I feel I can chip in with my own perspective on this question.
Antonymy : The semantic relation that holds between two words that can (in a given context) express opposite meanings [From WordWeb, emphasis mine]
Seems to be a good Definition, but this question is not about Antonyms, rather about what "opposite" means.
Opposite : "A word that expresses a meaning opposed to the meaning of another word, in which case the two words are antonyms of each other" & "Altogether different in nature, quality or significance" [From WordWeb, emphasis mine]
So if a word has many characteristics, then there can be many opposites, where atleast one characteristic is "negated".
Eg Father has characteristics (Male,Parent,Relative,Good,Carer,...) so opposites can be Mother (Male is negated Female) or Son (Parent is negated to Child) or Daughter (Male is negated Female & Parent is negated to Child) ...
What would be the opposite of Father in "My class teacher was like a Father who treated us like his children" ? The characteristic is "Good" and negate that to get "Bad", so "My class teacher was like a Tyrant who treated us like slaves". Of course, in general, nobody claims that the opposite of Father is Tyrant.
So I could say that "opposite" is either not really Well Defined, or any usage must state which Specific Context is being considered.
User Hippietrail rightly says that "antonym" is not really a "natural" or "God given" concept that it at first seems.
It may not matter much in daily life, but in language Exams, incorrect thinking on the part of the evaluators may result in incorrect evaluations of some "correct" answers. One way out would be to ask questions like "What is the Feminine opposite of Father ?" so that the context is shown.
edited Apr 13 '17 at 12:54
Community♦
1
1
answered Jun 11 '15 at 10:25
PremPrem
2,78121135
2,78121135
add a comment |
add a comment |
Not doesn't mean opposite. Animals that are not birds is the set of all animals minus birds - Not means 'exclusion'.
The opposite of 6 is negative 6 - opposite meaning a measurement of the same magnitude in the reverse direction of the same continuum.
So on the continuum of approval, or morality, good is the opposite of bad.
On the continuum of personal alliances a friend is the opposite of enemy.
But titles such as Uncle are not on any continuum, they have one specific meaning. There is no opposite of Doctor, Dentist, baseball or niece.
add a comment |
Not doesn't mean opposite. Animals that are not birds is the set of all animals minus birds - Not means 'exclusion'.
The opposite of 6 is negative 6 - opposite meaning a measurement of the same magnitude in the reverse direction of the same continuum.
So on the continuum of approval, or morality, good is the opposite of bad.
On the continuum of personal alliances a friend is the opposite of enemy.
But titles such as Uncle are not on any continuum, they have one specific meaning. There is no opposite of Doctor, Dentist, baseball or niece.
add a comment |
Not doesn't mean opposite. Animals that are not birds is the set of all animals minus birds - Not means 'exclusion'.
The opposite of 6 is negative 6 - opposite meaning a measurement of the same magnitude in the reverse direction of the same continuum.
So on the continuum of approval, or morality, good is the opposite of bad.
On the continuum of personal alliances a friend is the opposite of enemy.
But titles such as Uncle are not on any continuum, they have one specific meaning. There is no opposite of Doctor, Dentist, baseball or niece.
Not doesn't mean opposite. Animals that are not birds is the set of all animals minus birds - Not means 'exclusion'.
The opposite of 6 is negative 6 - opposite meaning a measurement of the same magnitude in the reverse direction of the same continuum.
So on the continuum of approval, or morality, good is the opposite of bad.
On the continuum of personal alliances a friend is the opposite of enemy.
But titles such as Uncle are not on any continuum, they have one specific meaning. There is no opposite of Doctor, Dentist, baseball or niece.
answered 2 hours ago
Randy ZeitmanRandy Zeitman
16818
16818
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to English Language & Usage Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fenglish.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f251198%2fwhat-does-opposite-mean%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
2
I'm afraid that opposite has multiple meanings language wise. So in this case maths and language are indeed different domains, no real comparison possible.
– Bookeater
Jun 8 '15 at 19:15
1
I fail to see how this is specific to English Language and Usage
– Tushar Raj
Jun 8 '15 at 19:26
@Bookeater , yes the question is about whether "opposite" has a fixed unambiguous meaning or not. I agree that it has many meanings, in general. In a specific case, I am worried why language textbooks (or Exams) will mark Father~Son , Father~Daughter as WRONG, because those are equally correct.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:09
@TusharRaj , I agree that this problem exists in many (all ?) other languages. Definitely it exists in English too. Unless a language has a FIXED Definition of Opposite, this problem will exist. Mathematics is exempted, because Opposite of "X" is "not X", with no ambiguity.
– Prem
Jun 9 '15 at 11:25
1
What do you mean - the opposite of "x" is "not x" in mathematics? In the common sense of "not", 6 is not 7, but 6 is not the opposite of 7, either. So what EXACTLY do "opposite" and "not" mean in mathematics?
– user316117
May 12 '16 at 18:38